· 5 min
SF commission opposes demolition rules unless changed; Oakland extends data center pause
San Francisco's Planning Commission recommends rejecting a supervisor's rules on replacing demolished homes unless they're changed. Oakland's City Council extends its data center moratorium, and San Jose's City Council proclaims a local emergency ahead of El Niño storms.
Download the MP3 · 5.0 MB
This episode is made with AI from each government's own show, which reports from the public recordings of its meetings. Sources are in the show notes.
Transcript
Headlines
00:00
Maya This is Bay Area in 5, from CivicFM: the week at the city halls and county boards we cover.
Maya San Francisco's Planning Commission pushed back on a supervisor's stricter rules for replacing demolished homes. Oakland's City Council extended its pause on data center approvals, and San Jose's City Council declared a local emergency ahead of El Niño storms.
“Oakland's City Council extended its pause on data center approvals, and San…” Oakland 00:07:58 San Jose 01:29:25
In the notes: Data center moratorium: 35-day report and ten-month extension
Maya This episode is made with AI from each government's own show, which reports from the public recordings of its meetings. Sources are in the show notes.
Read more: Supervisor's ordinance on replacing demolished housing in priority equity geographies (Board File 260836) · Data center moratorium: 35-day report and ten-month extension · El Niño flood preparedness and local emergency proclamation
Top story: San Francisco commission opposes demolition rules unless changed
00:44
Maya Our top story: San Francisco's rules for replacing torn-down homes. On November fifth, the city's Planning Commission voted five to two to recommend that the Board of Supervisors reject Supervisor Chyanne Chen's ordinance unless it's changed. In the city's priority equity geographies, her ordinance would require more replacement units to be affordable when tenant incomes aren't known: about sixty-nine percent, up from about fifty-one, by staff's count.
“Our top story: San Francisco's rules for replacing torn-down homes.” San Francisco 00:23:07
“On November fifth, the city's Planning Commission voted five to two to…” San Francisco 00:16:16 San Francisco 03:17:20
“In the city's priority equity geographies, her ordinance would require more…” San Francisco 00:38:49
Theo City staff warned that raising those obligations without offsets could make fewer projects feasible. About twenty public speakers backed the ordinance, including Chinatown residents and tenant groups. The supervisor said she'd accept some changes, but not dropping the deeper affordability those neighborhood rules require, which she called its core intent.
“City staff warned that raising those obligations without offsets could make…” San Francisco 00:44:26
“The supervisor said she'd accept some changes, but not dropping the deeper…” San Francisco 02:21:02
Maya The recommendation now goes to the Board of Supervisors. The commission also urged the board to strengthen protections for extremely low income tenants.
“The commission also urged the board to strengthen protections for extremely low…” San Francisco 03:17:20
Top story: Oakland extends data center moratorium by ten and a half months
01:47
Theo Next, to Oakland, where the City Council voted eight to nothing on Tuesday to extend its emergency moratorium on data center approvals by ten and a half months. City staff said the extension carries their work through October fifth of next year. In that time they'll draft rules on where data centers could go, with limits on power, water and air quality.
“Next, to Oakland, where the City Council voted eight to nothing on Tuesday to…” Oakland 01:32:20 Oakland 00:07:58
“City staff said the extension carries their work through October fifth of next…” Oakland 00:07:58 Oakland 00:19:43
“In that time they'll draft rules on where data centers could go, with limits on…” Oakland 00:07:58
In the notes: Data center moratorium: 35-day report and ten-month extension
Maya About thirty-four people spoke. Roughly thirty backed the extension, many citing West Oakland's pollution, its health disparities and higher utility bills, and about ten called for an eventual permanent ban. A few speakers wanted data centers allowed, citing jobs.
Theo Before new rules come back to the full council, they're to go through a Planning Commission hearing and council committees.
Read more: Data center moratorium: 35-day report and ten-month extension
Top story: San Jose proclaims local emergency ahead of El Niño storms
02:35
Maya Our third story takes us to San Jose, where the City Council on Tuesday unanimously proclaimed a local emergency ahead of a forecast El Niño storm season. Staff said that speeds up getting emergency equipment and resources in place. Last month we told you the council asked staff to work with Valley Water on a ranked list of flood hotspots. The joint plan presented Tuesday identifies fifty-nine.
“Our third story takes us to San Jose, where the City Council on Tuesday…” San Jose 01:29:25 San Jose 00:37:31
“Staff said that speeds up getting emergency equipment and resources in place.” San Jose 00:37:31 San Jose 00:59:50
“Last month we told you the council asked staff to work with Valley Water on a…” San Jose 00:44:04
“The joint plan presented Tuesday identifies fifty-nine.” San Jose 00:44:04
In the notes: El Niño flood preparedness and local emergency proclamation
Theo The environmental services director warned that much of the city's creek system has no engineered levees, and that storm drains are built for a once-in-ten-year rain. A presenter reminded residents that flood insurance takes thirty days to kick in. Staff will report back every sixty days on whether to keep the emergency in place.
“The environmental services director warned that much of the city's creek system…” San Jose 00:37:31 San Jose 00:39:41
“A presenter reminded residents that flood insurance takes thirty days to kick…” San Jose 00:58:13
“Staff will report back every sixty days on whether to keep the emergency in…” San Jose 01:00:54
In the notes: El Niño flood preparedness and local emergency proclamation
Read more: El Niño flood preparedness and local emergency proclamation
Around the area
03:22
Maya Now a few more decisions from around the area. San Jose's council also unanimously backed a plan to wind down First Community Housing, an affordable housing developer whose roughly twenty properties house about four thousand people. City staff said the portfolio is financially distressed, and the wind-down is planned over about eighteen months.
“San Jose's council also unanimously backed a plan to wind down First Community…” San Jose 01:48:35 San Jose 01:32:41
“City staff said the portfolio is financially distressed, and the wind-down is…” San Jose 01:32:41 San Jose 01:37:25
In the notes: Stabilizing First Community Housing's troubled affordable housing portfolio
Theo In a nine to one vote, with Vice Mayor Pam Foley recused, San Jose's council gave first approval to changes in Apple's North San Jose development agreement. The changes remove about nine point seven acres that Apple is selling to PG&E for an electrical substation, and Apple would put two and a half million dollars toward a bike crossing at Trimble Road. A related vote that could eventually close part of Orchard Parkway, a bike route, passed eight to two, with Foley again recused.
“In a nine to one vote, with Vice Mayor Pam Foley recused, San Jose's council…” San Jose 02:21:44 In the notes
“The changes remove about nine point seven acres that Apple is selling to PG&E…” San Jose 01:50:40 In the notes
“A related vote that could eventually close part of Orchard Parkway, a bike…” San Jose 02:21:51 San Jose 02:27:02 In the notes
Maya Oakland's council split five to two, with one abstention, to extend three executive search firm contracts and add seventy-five thousand dollars for one firm. Two weeks ago we told you the council's Finance and Management Committee had recommended just that amount, down from a three hundred thousand dollar request. Councilmember Janani Ramachandran, who chairs that committee, voted no, arguing the city spends too much on headhunting firms.
“Oakland's council split five to two, with one abstention, to extend three…” Oakland 01:52:01
“Councilmember Janani Ramachandran, who chairs that committee, voted no, arguing…” Oakland 01:52:01 Oakland 01:36:03
In the notes: Executive recruitment firm contracts extended, with $75,000 more for one firm
Theo And San Francisco's Board of Supervisors unanimously gave final approval to making the Jefferson Airplane House on Fulton Street a city landmark.
“And San Francisco's Board of Supervisors unanimously gave final approval to…” San Francisco 00:18:56 San Francisco 00:18:12
Read more: Stabilizing First Community Housing's troubled affordable housing portfolio · Amending Apple's North San Jose development agreement · Conditional vacation of part of Orchard Parkway · Executive recruitment firm contracts extended, with $75,000 more for one firm · Consent agenda: District 7 spending, rooftop restrooms, Jefferson Airplane House landmark, tenant-protection notices
Sign-off
04:52
Maya That's the week around the Bay Area. See you next time.
The stories
From this week's episodes of San Francisco, Oakland and San Jose.
San Francisco · Planning Commission Thursday, November 5
1 item
San Francisco's episode · The recording · Agenda
Supervisor's ordinance on replacing demolished housing in priority equity geographies (Board File 260836) Item 8
Affordable housingRenters and tenantsZoning and plans
This ordinance, introduced by Chyanne Chen (Supervisor, District 11), changes the Planning Code and Zoning Map. It sets how many affordable units a developer must build to replace homes it tears down. As drafted, it would: extend the citywide look-back period for one-to-one replacement of housing from five to seven years; in the Priority Equity Geographies Special Use District (PEG SUD), use neighborhood-specific federal CHAS data when tenant incomes are unknown, which raises the affordable share of replacement units from about 51% to about 69% and, for rental projects, adds an extremely low income tier (30% of area median income) at about 41%; in PEG SUD rental projects, replace rent-controlled units held by moderate- or higher-income tenants with deed-restricted units at 80% AMI instead of rent-controlled units; add about 30 blocks south of Ocean Avenue to the PEG SUD; and, citywide, switch replacement units to the Mayor's Office of Housing and Community Development (MOHCD) income limits, which are lower than the state's, plus cleanup amendments. Staff recommended a new kind of action, disapproval unless modified, with three changes: keep the five-year look-back, delete the PEG SUD-specific replacement requirements, and delete the map amendment. The commission's recommendation goes to the Board of Supervisors. 00:16:16
More on San Francisco's episode
- Mike Chen (Commissioner) moved to adopt a recommendation of disapproval unless modified, following the staff recommendation, and to encourage the Board of Supervisors to increase protections for extremely low income tenants; seconded by Joel Koppel (Commissioner; Vice President, Planning Commission). Result: passed, 5-2. No: Malea Chavez (Commissioner), Elizabeth Macdonald (Commissioner). 03:17:20
- The sponsoring supervisor described the ordinance as a narrow change to replacement-housing standards for projects that tear down existing homes in priority equity geographies 00:23:07
- The sponsoring supervisor said state law, including SB 330, allows local rules on demolition that protect lower-income households more 00:19:58
- The sponsoring supervisor said 52% of the city's low income renters live in the priority equity geographies 00:27:12
- City staff explained that the ordinance extends the replacement look-back from five to seven years citywide 00:28:12
- City staff explained that staff was proposing a new kind of recommendation, disapproval unless modified, backed by separate findings of consistency and inconsistency with the General Plan 00:31:14
- City staff said demolitions are rare in San Francisco, averaging about 18 units a year since 2012 00:34:28
- City staff said that since the tenant protection ordinance took effect in February 2026 the department has received eight demolition applications, none of them in the PEG SUD 00:35:32
- City staff said citywide data now require about 51% of replacement units to be affordable when incomes are unknown, and PEG-specific data would raise that to about 69% 00:38:49
- City staff said MOHCD income limits are roughly 23% lower than the state's, which would mean deeper affordability citywide 00:40:53
- City staff argued that raising replacement obligations without offsetting measures could make fewer housing projects financially feasible 00:44:26
- City staff said that in the department's example of a 25-unit rental replacing a five-unit rent-controlled building, the proposal would make 20% of the project affordable, four times the inclusionary requirement 00:45:32
- City staff warned the proposal could push projects from rental to ownership housing and take away moderate-income tenants' right to return 00:46:35
- City staff said extremely low income units work best with dedicated subsidies and services that market-rate buildings lack 00:48:44
- City staff advised against adding the 30 blocks to the PEG SUD now, saying it would set a precedent for parcel-by-parcel changes 00:49:47
- Mike Chen (Commissioner) asked how current law protects single-room-occupancy (SRO) hotel units from demolition 01:56:28
- City staff said every demolition inside the PEG SUD still requires a commission hearing, and that the hotel conversion ordinance requires one-for-one replacement of SRO units or an equivalent fee 01:58:12
- City staff said that when tenant incomes are known, replacement units must be deed-restricted at the tenant's income level, at the current rent or an affordable rent, whichever is lower 02:02:02
- City staff said staff knows of no SRO units demolished through these processes in its records 02:03:24
- City staff confirmed that under the proposal, moderate-income tenants would lose their right to return in rental projects 02:09:47
- Mike Chen (Commissioner) worried that deeper affordability requirements would make replacement projects infeasible 02:12:06
- Mike Chen (Commissioner) argued that subsidies for very low income housing should come from sources like the housing trust fund, and said he leaned toward the staff recommendation 02:13:06
- Sean McGarry (Commissioner) said the city needs to build more and the change is not economically feasible now, and backed the recommendation because it keeps the conversation going 02:16:15
- A commissioner asked whether the supervisor's office and the department could still work out their differences before the commission acted 02:17:15
- The sponsoring supervisor said she was open to some amendments but not to staff's recommendation two, which she called the legislation's core intent 02:21:02
- City staff said the department's central sticking point is that new constraints on development must be offset, but that it remains open to other solutions 02:22:30
- Lydia So (Commissioner) framed the question as whether the ordinance would actually protect the tenants it targets, and said it would create a parallel rulebook for an area with no demolition applications this year 02:26:36
- Lydia So (Commissioner) argued that extremely low income households are better served through the housing trust fund that voters expanded with Prop C, and said she would support the staff recommendation 02:29:42
- Lydia So (Commissioner) asked staff to track demolition-rule outcomes in the PEG and return with further cleanup, including making the right of first refusal automatic 02:32:46
- A commissioner praised the community input but said he would side with the staff recommendation, citing builders' need for predictability and feasibility 02:37:16
- The supervisor's legislative aide explained that the 30 added blocks meet the public health vulnerability criteria originally used to draw the priority equity geographies 02:39:33
- The sponsoring supervisor said she was open to dropping the map amendment and keeping the five-year look-back 02:41:27
- Elizabeth Macdonald (Commissioner) argued that a citywide standard is not an equitable standard, and suggested that problems with extremely low income units could be addressed in later legislation 02:43:35
- A commissioner said that in her eviction defense work as an attorney, seniors on fixed incomes are the fastest-growing group she sees, and opposed letting uncertain feasibility block the legislation 02:52:31
- The commission president said the tenant protection ordinance is already strong, expressed concern about the feasibility findings, and leaned toward disapproval unless modified 02:55:34
- City staff said the commission must send its recommendation to the clerk by December 17, and that missing the deadline counts as a de facto disapproval 02:58:26
- The sponsoring supervisor said she could also accept keeping rent-controlled replacement units, if the department commits to finding ways to provide extremely low income units 03:00:34
- A commissioner proposed voting on the staff recommendations separately; staff said the commission must take one comprehensive action 03:07:45
- The sponsoring supervisor stressed that the ordinance concerns replacing demolished homes rather than new inclusionary units, and that the Controller's feasibility study addressed inclusionary units 03:14:36
San Francisco · Board of Supervisors Tuesday, November 10
1 item
San Francisco's episode · The recording · Agenda · Agenda outline
Consent agenda: District 7 spending, rooftop restrooms, Jefferson Airplane House landmark, tenant-protection notices Item 2-5
Renters and tenantsHistoric preservationZoning and plans
Four ordinances given final passage together without discussion: District 7 project spending, a Planning Code height exemption for rooftop restrooms, landmark status for the Jefferson Airplane House at 2400 Fulton Street, and a rule requiring landlords to notify tenants of rent-increase limits, just-cause eviction rules and certificate-of-occupancy dates. 00:18:12
More on San Francisco's episode
- Final passage of consent items 2 through 5. Result: passed, 11-0. 00:18:56
Oakland · City Council Tuesday, November 10
2 items
Oakland's episode · The recording · Agenda
Data center moratorium: 35-day report and ten-month extension Item 4.1
Zoning and plansPollutionEnergy
The council had adopted a 45-day emergency moratorium (Interim Emergency Ordinance No. 13899 C.M.S.) on approving any land use entitlements or agreements for developing or operating data centers in Oakland. Staff said it was adopted October 6 and would expire November 20. State law (Government Code 65858(d)) requires a written report within 35 days on steps taken; the council held a public hearing on that report and on an emergency ordinance (file 27-0178) extending the moratorium for ten months and fifteen days, which under the City Charter could be adopted the same day but needed seven votes. Staff said the extension would carry the work through October 5, 2027, while it drafts zoning rules covering where data centers could go and limits on power, water and air quality. 00:07:58
- Carroll Fife (Councilmember, District 3; Chair, Life Enrichment Committee) moved, seconded by Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee), to open the public hearing. Result: passed, 8-0. 00:08:20
- Carroll Fife (Councilmember, District 3; Chair, Life Enrichment Committee) moved, seconded by Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee), to close the public hearing and adopt both pieces of legislation: the resolution issuing the 35-day report, and the emergency ordinance extending the data center moratorium for ten months and fifteen days. Result: passed, 8-0. 01:32:20
- City staff explained that state law requires a 35-day report on the work done under the 45-day moratorium 00:10:16
- City staff said the 45-day moratorium was adopted October 6 and expires November 20 00:11:20
- City staff cited other cities with data center moratoriums, including San Francisco, Gilroy, Oakley, El Monte and Richmond, and said Richmond adopted a 22.5-month extension 00:13:26
- City staff said staff is consulting utilities and regulators, including PG&E and the air quality district, with particular concern about backup generators 00:16:34
- City staff said the city plans to hire outside consultants because of the expertise this facility type requires 00:17:37
- City staff asked for the ten-month, fifteen-day extension allowed by state law, saying it would carry the work through October 5, 2027 00:19:43
- A councilmember said two major tech companies have leased space in West Oakland and another has shown interest in a downtown site 00:20:38
- A councilmember said the moratorium is not a rejection of technology or economic growth but guardrails on the industry 00:21:39
- A councilmember objected to companies requiring officials and landlords to sign nondisclosure agreements, which keeps the public uninformed 00:22:44
- A councilmember cited public health data showing West Oakland life expectancy six to seven and a half years below the county average 00:23:46
- A councilmember asked staff for a list of land and properties available for development in Oakland 00:26:32
- A councilmember said the city pays to lease space for police and public works, citing $4 million a year near the Coliseum, while public land goes unused 00:27:33
- The council president asked staff to send the council a supplemental list of properties that might be available 00:28:28
- Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) asked which city departments will help with the regulatory research 00:29:08
- City staff named economic development, race and equity, and information technology, plus public works and transportation 00:29:44
- Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) asked for an implementation timeline, such as choosing consultants within 90 days 00:30:43
- Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) asked for a report back within 30 days on the community engagement plan, regulatory research and consultant procurement 00:32:03
- City staff offered to set up regular updates with the department 00:32:26
- City staff said the project website should be updated before the end of the year 00:33:08
- A councilmember urged that the definition of a data center not end up restricting light manufacturing and industrial uses 00:33:19
- A councilmember said massive GPU farms have no place in Oakland 00:33:19
- A councilmember suggested the threshold could rest on wattage, water use, power use or square footage 00:34:22
- City staff said staff is also considering a place-based approach, allowing some facilities in some areas and not others 00:34:39
- A councilmember thanked a community group that surveyed more than 400 West Oakland residents and shared its data 00:35:18
- Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) said cannabis operations in his district haven't been monitored, and asked who will enforce the moratorium and regulations 00:39:13
- City staff said Planning and Building will lead enforcement and may lean on other departments such as fire 00:40:05
Executive recruitment firm contracts extended, with $75,000 more for one firm Item 5.1
Contracts and purchasingPublic employees
The city uses three outside executive search firms (Ralph Andersen & Associates, The Hawkins Company, and CPS HR Consulting) to recruit senior leaders. As posted, the item would extend all three contracts through August 31, 2027, add $200,000 to Ralph Andersen (from $250,000 to $450,000) and $100,000 to Hawkins (from $250,000 to $350,000), and waive competitive bidding and local/small business requirements (agenda). The Finance and Management Committee had cut the increases to $75,000 for Ralph Andersen only, and staff brought that reduced version to the council. Staff said the money would finish recruitments already under way, including for constitutional policing, and a search for a permanent city administrator. 01:32:20
- Zac Unger (Councilmember, District 1; Chair, Public Works and Transportation Committee) moved, seconded by Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee), to approve the staff recommendation as presented: extend all three executive search contracts and add $75,000 to the Ralph Andersen & Associates contract. Result: passed, 5-2, 1 abstention. No: Noel Gallo (Councilmember, District 5; President Pro Tempore), Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee). Abstained: Carroll Fife (Councilmember, District 3; Chair, Life Enrichment Committee). 01:52:01
- City staff said the city will start a new request for proposals for executive search firms and temporary services 01:35:03
- A councilmember confirmed with staff that the request reflects the committee's cut from $200,000 to $75,000, then moved approval 01:35:29
- Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee) said her committee no vote is why the item was on non-consent, and that she opposes any increase to the Ralph Andersen contract 01:36:03
- Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee) argued the city spends too much on headhunting firms and often gets poor results 01:36:03
- Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee) said HR staff can recruit in house, and objected that the firms are not local small businesses 01:37:05
- A councilmember argued the city should train and promote its own employees into leadership instead of hiring from outside 01:38:50
- Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) said at first he would also vote no, citing the waiver and the firms not being local 01:42:42
- City staff said the contract is needed to finish the constitutional policing recruitment and the Mayor's priority recruitment 01:43:03
- City staff apologized for the administration for not bringing the request in a timely and transparent way 01:43:50
- City staff said the Mayor wants a professional search firm to recruit the city administrator 01:44:51
- City staff said staff will return to move some of the Hawkins contract authority to Ralph Andersen at no added cost 01:44:51
- Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) said the assistant city administrator's explanation led him to change his vote to yes 01:46:00
- City staff said Measure EE created a new council office whose chief would likely be recruited through a search firm 01:47:28
- City staff listed the recruitments: Head Start program director, Human Services director, Constitutional Policing administrator, and Budget administrator 01:48:46
- Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee) urged the same effort and money go to entry-level hiring, such as Head Start teachers she said earn barely $18 an hour 01:50:12
San Jose · City Council Tuesday, November 10
4 items
San Jose's episode · The recording · Agenda · Agenda
El Niño flood preparedness and local emergency proclamation Item 3.3
Emergency preparednessStreets and public works
A joint city and Valley Water report on preparing for a forecast, potentially historic El Niño storm season, and a resolution proclaiming a local emergency under Chapter 8.08 of the Municipal Code to match the Governor's state of emergency and organize city resources (agenda). Staff said the proclamation lets the city move faster on acquiring emergency equipment and resources and that they will return every 60 days on whether to keep it in place. 00:37:31
- Rosemary Kamei (Councilmember, District 1) moved to accept the report and adopt the resolution proclaiming a local emergency under Chapter 8.08; seconded (seconder not identified). Result: passed, unanimous. 01:29:25
- The environmental services director warned that much of San Jose's creek system is natural channel without engineered levees and can overflow in heavy or prolonged rain. 00:37:31
- The environmental services director urged all residents to sign up for county emergency alerts, noting you don't have to live by a creek to be flooded. 00:38:31
- The environmental services director explained that the storm drain system is built for a once-in-ten-year rain, so street flooding in bigger storms is expected. 00:39:41
- City staff said the joint plan identifies 59 flood hotspots from past experience, but flooding can happen elsewhere too. 00:44:04
- City staff added that the transportation department monitors 22 more locations. 00:45:04
- City staff described four response levels (preparedness, monitoring, watch, warning) tied to how full the creeks are, with creeks currently under 50% at the lowest level. 00:46:06
- The environmental services director said Upper Penitencia Creek can only carry a two-year storm and has no federal funding for improvements. 00:48:04
- A guest presenter said the second phase of Valley Water's Coyote Creek project will be done by 2028, giving roughly the capacity of the 2017 flood event. 00:49:55
- A guest presenter said the federal Upper Guadalupe River project is years away, with a chief's report around 2031 or 2032, so Valley Water is pursuing interim protection. 00:50:57
- A guest presenter reported about 167 stream maintenance projects this season, about 126 of them vegetation removal and bank stabilization. 00:53:08
- A guest presenter said there are five county sandbag sites, three of them in San Jose, with webcams showing supply. 00:57:07
- A guest presenter reminded residents that flood insurance takes 30 days to take effect, so it must be bought before the rain. 00:58:13
- City staff reported 63 new CERT graduates since July and nearly 100 registered for the December course. 00:59:50
- City staff said the emergency proclamation lets the city acquire and place emergency equipment and resources. 00:59:50
- City staff said staff would return to the council every 60 days on whether to keep or end the local emergency. 01:00:54
- Rosemary Kamei (Councilmember, District 1) asked whether the agencies are seeking permit waivers to clear the worst debris blockages this year. 01:06:39
- A guest presenter said a second governor's proclamation waived many state Fish and Wildlife permits, but state water board permits are still required. 01:07:23
- A guest presenter said San Jose is seeking emergency permits for some of the worst locations along Coyote Creek. 01:08:24
- Rosemary Kamei (Councilmember, District 1) urged a joint push to get the worst sites cleared before the storms, then moved the recommendation. 01:08:55
- A councilmember promoted a Friday walk along the Guadalupe River with Anthony Tordillos (Councilmember, District 3), a Valley Water board member, and an engineer about El Niño preparedness. 01:10:43
- Domingo Candelas (Councilmember, District 8) asked for sandbag sites closer to outlying districts, such as community centers or libraries, after hearing concerns at a mobile home park near Thompson Creek. 01:13:46
- A guest presenter said Valley Water would coordinate with the city on additional or smaller sandbag sites. 01:15:04
- Anthony Tordillos (Councilmember, District 3) praised the Coyote Mudlarks' advocacy and the agencies' efforts with state and regional water boards to streamline debris removal. 01:16:09
- A guest presenter said the Upper Penitencia project runs from I-680 to just past King Road, and Valley Water hopes to use exemptions for sediment removal next year. 01:17:58
- David Cohen (Councilmember, District 4) faulted Valley Water for delaying the long-planned King Road Bridge widening and urged combining it with the creek work. 01:19:43
- The mayor asked that information sessions target neighborhoods nearest the hotspots of greatest concern. 01:20:36
- A guest presenter said Valley Water is hanging about 48,000 door hangers and running a media campaign, including movie and streaming ads. 01:21:26
- The environmental services director said two webinars are planned on Valley Water's flood-ready map. 01:22:28
- The mayor asked how well the agencies can monitor, verify, and alert residents in real time across about 60 hotspots. 01:23:58
- A guest presenter said Valley Water is confident in its monitoring and keeps a staffed 24-hour line for reporting blockages. 01:24:39
- City staff said field crews log conditions with photos on internal dashboards, partly to document the emergency for federal reimbursement. 01:26:31
- City staff described outreach to unhoused people along creeks, including multilingual broadcasts from police vehicles. 01:27:58
Stabilizing First Community Housing's troubled affordable housing portfolio Item 8.1
Affordable housing
First Community Housing, an affordable housing developer, owns about 20 properties housing roughly 4,000 people; staff said the portfolio is financially distressed and the corporation is to be wound down. The council considered a forgivable loan of up to $1,500,000 to pay for consultants, a Memorandum of Understanding with First Community Housing, and a $1,500,000 increase to the city loan for Curtner Studios at 701 Curtner Avenue (from $5,042,845 to $6,542,845), funded by moving $3,000,000 from the Housing Project Reserve (agenda). Two council memos were attached: one from Matt Mahan (Mayor), Pam Foley (Councilmember, District 9; Vice Mayor), Anthony Tordillos (Councilmember, District 3) and Michael Mulcahy (Councilmember, District 6), and one from George Casey (Councilmember, District 10), Rosemary Kamei (Councilmember, District 1), Pamela Campos (Councilmember, District 2), David Cohen (Councilmember, District 4) and Domingo Candelas (Councilmember, District 8). 01:32:41
- Anthony Tordillos (Councilmember, District 3) moved approval of the staff recommendation along with both group memos. Result: passed, unanimous. 01:48:35
- The housing director said the city has invested about $125 million in the portfolio, more than $60 million of it in recent years. 01:33:45
- The housing director blamed inadequate underwriting and insufficient financial oversight for the portfolio's distress. 01:33:45
- A housing deputy director said the portfolio has about 20 properties and 1,400 units housing about 4,000 people, and named Curtner and 2nd Street Studios as the most distressed. 01:35:16
- A housing deputy director said the plan is to wind down the corporation over about 18 months, transferring properties to qualified developers. 01:37:25
- A housing deputy director said the overall portfolio has negative value and the city may trade debt forgiveness for upfront cash. 01:37:25
- The housing director said the $1.5 million to the corporation would hire three consultants experienced in disposing of distressed portfolios. 01:38:32
- The housing director said Curtner Studios has little or no site management and serious roofing problems, which the extra $1.5 million would address. 01:38:32
- The housing director said the corporation has no staff, so the consultants would do most of the work. 01:40:40
- The mayor said overly optimistic projections for deeply affordable housing put residents at risk. 01:41:09
- The mayor backed both group memos, saying his memo stressed strong oversight of how the properties are disposed of. 01:42:11
- Anthony Tordillos (Councilmember, District 3) said the situation shows why the housing department's stricter underwriting of new projects matters. 01:42:54
- Anthony Tordillos (Councilmember, District 3) backed the second memo's idea of possible strategic acquisitions if the cost is right, and moved both memos. 01:43:54
- A councilmember recounted Curtner Studios' decline despite a 2024 city reinvestment and thanked housing, police, and fire for stepping in when management walked off the job. 01:45:16
- A councilmember said the second memo aims to give housing staff room to consider acquisitions and act quickly when they report back quarterly. 01:46:44
- The mayor cautioned that city acquisition of these properties is in many cases unlikely to reduce costs. 01:46:58
Amending Apple's North San Jose development agreement Item 10.2
Development projectsEnergyBiking and walking
Amends Apple's 2016 development agreement for its land along Orchard Parkway and Component Drive in North San Jose (Council District 4). It removes about 9.7 acres fronting North 1st Street that Apple is selling to PG&E for a new electrical substation, and ties a future closure of part of Orchard Parkway to Apple's construction. In return Apple contributes $2.5 million toward a Trimble Road bike crossing, Class IV bike lanes on Component Drive, and $90,000 for transit signal priority. The Planning Commission recommended approval 8-0-3 (agenda). A memo from Matt Mahan (Mayor), David Cohen (Councilmember, District 4) and Michael Mulcahy (Councilmember, District 6) was attached. Pam Foley (Councilmember, District 9; Vice Mayor) recused herself from this item and item 3.4. 01:50:40
- David Cohen (Councilmember, District 4) moved approval of the group memo from Matt Mahan (Mayor), David Cohen (Councilmember, District 4) and Michael Mulcahy (Councilmember, District 6), including the staff recommendation (CEQA addendum and the ordinance approving the first amendment), with continued talks with Apple on bike access. Result: passed, 9-1. No: Bien Doan (Councilmember, District 7). Recused: Pam Foley (Councilmember, District 9; Vice Mayor). 02:21:44
- The vice mayor said she was recusing herself because her husband has a financial interest in Apple stock. 01:50:56
- City staff said the original agreement dates from March 2016 and runs until March 2031. 01:51:31
- City staff said PG&E approached Apple to buy land on the site's 1st Street frontage for a substation to power North San Jose's growth. 01:53:41
- City staff said the amendment removes 9.7 acres for the PG&E sale. 01:54:44
- City staff said Orchard Parkway would not close right away; closure is tied to actual future development. 01:54:44
- City staff said Apple would contribute $2.5 million toward a crossing at Trimble where the Guadalupe River Trail underpass floods. 01:55:46
- City staff said Apple would also build protected bike lanes on Component Drive and give $90,000 for transit priority signals. 01:55:46
- David Cohen (Councilmember, District 4) said he was initially skeptical of the substation's location but came to see it as the only option for improving power reliability in North San Jose. 02:02:59
- City staff confirmed that the first building permit triggers many of the conditions, including the Trimble crossing, before the street would close. 02:04:33
- David Cohen (Councilmember, District 4) said his memo seeks talks with Apple on a bike connection from the Charcot side to the Guadalupe River Trail, with no specific route set yet. 02:06:01
- City staff said he did not know how the $90,000 transit figure was set. 02:08:27
- City staff said staff expects Apple to seek a renegotiation and extension of the agreement within a couple of years, a chance to seek more benefits. 02:09:36
- City staff said the city has very limited control over the substation's design, which goes through the CPUC. 02:11:16
- A councilmember urged pressing PG&E to soften the substation's 1st Street face with landscaping or other treatment at a major gateway. 02:11:53
- City staff said it will be a gas-insulated substation housed in buildings, and PG&E has discussed walls with possible art and added landscaping. 02:13:47
- Rosemary Kamei (Councilmember, District 1) asked why the city should approve vacating the road now if Apple won't close it right away. 02:16:10
- City staff said the agreement keeps the road open if Apple doesn't build. 02:17:57
- City staff said the 2005 North San Jose plan called for 16 million square feet of office and R&D, but only one hotel has been built since. 02:17:57
- Rosemary Kamei (Councilmember, District 1) argued that any mitigation for closing the road, such as bike access, belongs in the development agreement itself, not in side conversations. 02:20:21
Conditional vacation of part of Orchard Parkway Item 3.4
Streets and public worksDevelopment projectsBiking and walking
A public hearing on conditionally vacating Orchard Parkway from Orchard Place to Component Drive, and Orchard Place (formerly Atmel Way) entirely, keeping a public service easement. The street would be vacated only after set conditions are met (agenda), allowing Apple to consolidate its campus. The street is used as a bike route parallel to North 1st Street. 02:21:51
- Motion to approve the conditional vacation resolution (mover not identified); seconded. Result: passed, 8-2. No: Rosemary Kamei (Councilmember, District 1), Bien Doan (Councilmember, District 7). Recused: Pam Foley (Councilmember, District 9; Vice Mayor). 02:27:02